S14 Ep. 7 / Uncovering the Story Behind Sexual Struggle with Jay Stringer

Alex Kocher (00:02.072)

Well, I don't think I'm alone in asking myself the question, why do I keep returning to the very thing I don't want to do? So whether it's pornography or alcohol or food, people pleasing, anxiety, or just a pattern that just discourages you, I think many of us know what it feels like to feel stuck, to just wanna try harder, pray more, make new promises and then end up right back where we started.

So today we're excited that our guest invites us to ask some really difficult questions, but and different different questions. Instead of only asking, like, how do I stop? He encourages us to be curious and ask, what is this struggle actually trying to tell me? So our guest today is Dre Stringer, and he's just a renowned therapist. He's a researcher and he's an award-winning author who reveals how desire shapes everything.

Who we love, what we chase, and the life we create. So Jay, we're so excited that you're here and we're excited to introduce our count conversational counseling community to you and your work.

Brenda Payne (01:01.734)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (01:08.264)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (01:08.526)

Alex, Brenda, thank you so much for having me.

Brenda Payne (01:13.392)

Of course. It's just really our joy, Jay. I just want to tell you that when I I read your book Unwanted, it was hard for me to read because it actually was reading me. And

Alex Kocher (01:23.426)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (01:25.104)

Really and truly, for I think it was the first time that I really began myself to consider the deeper longings and desires that were underneath my own unwanted sexual behaviors from childhood up until about my early adult years. And interestingly enough, as I'm reading it and I've got 30 years of counseling experience, I'm like, I think I'm beginning to understand why I feel a little uncomfortable talking to people about certain aspects of their sexual brokenness as well, right? And I'm going like, wait, I

Alex Kocher (01:50.613)

Mm. Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (01:52.709)

Yes.

Brenda Payne (01:54.971)

I'm 60 years old and I'm realizing the shame that I'm stuck in because of what has been done to me or the behaviors that I participated in. And so I just want to say thank you. I I I feel like it kind of opened up a

gosh, maybe a little bit of a can of worms that I had stuffed down and really didn't want to. And I find myself self still saying, I I need to go back and continue to work through that. I need to find somebody to to probably work with me on that as well. And I I know I'm not alone. I know many of our listeners would feel the same way. So I would love for our listeners to hear a little bit about your personal story and what drew you into this particular work and then what ultimately led you to write unwanted.

Alex Kocher (02:14.125)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (02:25.621)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (02:35.503)

Hmm. Yeah, the first thing that comes to mind is my middle school self would be horrified if it knew that I I would be writing a book on unwanted sexual behavior and exploring sexual fantasies. So this is not the life that I've predicted for myself. So

Alex Kocher (02:48.224)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (02:48.52)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (02:53.601)

Ha ha ha.

Jay Stringer (02:54.183)

I I will often say that ⁓ learning about sex in the church or in a Christian family can be a little bit like going to a culinary school that will only teach you about food poisoning in Salmonella, but then somehow has like the audacity to ask of a masterpiece out of you.

Brenda Payne (02:54.427)

Ha ha ha.

Brenda Payne (03:00.158)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (03:06.837)

Yeah Yes.

Brenda Payne (03:07.572)

I love that.

Alex Kocher (03:13.623)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (03:13.827)

And so ⁓ I I think about that category of Romans twelve, too, of do not be conform to the patterns of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. You know, most of the churches and families that I was you know connected to growing up understood that first half of we don't want to be conformed to the patterns of, you know, promiscuity to p0rn0graphy to infidelity.

Brenda Payne (03:14.225)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (03:24.173)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (03:41.413)

But they had no really framework of how to renew your sexual mind. So I went through puberty while attending a Southern Baptist high school in Virginia, a horrible experience that I would not wish on many people. But one of the things that happened was, you know, around the age of fourteen or fifteen.

Alex Kocher (03:46.605)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (03:57.14)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (04:02.487)

A lot of the adolescent boys would begin to have these unspoken prayer requests that would come up on the chalkboard. And we were joking about this at my 20-year high school reunion. And it was that sense of what were your unspoken prayer requests about? And all the guys around the table were like, it was lust, it was masturbation. And so that that sense of like we're not supposed to do that. But we never had sex ed that was scientifically accurate.

Alex Kocher (04:11.501)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (04:12.222)

Hmm.

Brenda Payne (04:24.18)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (04:32.185)

And so just when I was getting some training under a sex therapist many years ago, one of the things she said is that when you are an adolescent boy, you have something like just imagine like a a shot glass of testosterone in your system. By the time that you reach the age of fifteen, that's a pint glass. And so you have a 20x increase in testosterone. And then if you're growing up in a Christian message that conflates arousal.

Alex Kocher (04:51.757)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (04:52.296)

Hm.

Brenda Payne (04:56.659)

Wow.

Jay Stringer (05:00.185)

With sin in some spiritual darkness unfolding, it's just such a petri dish. And then for women and girls in my high school, they had it so much worse. So it wasn't just stay pure, it was also keep other people from stumbling. And then marriage is presented as as this carrot where you're gonna be able to outgrow these pornographic patterns. And then some of the best selling books in this space will actually say to women.

Alex Kocher (05:06.817)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (05:16.203)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (05:16.265)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (05:28.375)

If your husband is outgrowing porn, present your body as a merciful vial of methadone to them. And it's like not only is that a horrible framework of marriage, but what do you think that does to things like desire? It's repellent. Like you're not gonna desire someone if you just feel like you have to tend to them and make sure that they don't act out. So

Alex Kocher (05:34.53)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (05:34.892)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (05:43.437)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (05:51.755)

All of that to say, I feel like

Jay Stringer (07:18.019)

So i so much of the framework that I had received was really lust management, which would be that internet monitoring, bouncing your eyes, get into some level of accountability. But as I was kind of going through the writing process, I had a conversation with my old youth pastor, and one of the things he said is when I've been having the same conversation with my accountability partner for fifteen years, like something isn't working.

Brenda Payne (07:45.31)

Right.

Jay Stringer (07:45.422)

And so Desmond Tutu has this great line originally talking about apartheid, but he said, There comes a point where we need to stop pulling people out of the river. We need to be able to go upstream to find out why they're falling in. And so Unwanted was that upstream book of

Alex Kocher (08:00.173)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (08:00.211)

Yeah.

Hmm.

Jay Stringer (08:04.953)

It not just like why do people watch porn? Why do people have infidelity? Like we already know the statistics. It's discouraging, it's ubiquitous, but I wanted to understand, you know, why do people do that? Why do people go towards self-sabotage? And one of the things that was pretty uncomfortable for some of the research participants is we we didn't just ask them, you know, were you pursuing infidelity or did you watch porn?

But we really began to ask them, like, when you go to Google, when you go to that porn site, what searches do you actually put in? what are the things that arouse you? Why do you keep going to those types of genres within pornography? So we wanted to learn not just, you know, why do people do this, but like how could we begin to predict what types of behaviors, what types of fantasies people would have? So

We did a really big research study, about thirty, eight hundred men and women participated in it. And we can unpack more of it. But the the gist of that is that unwanted sexual behaviors are not random. They're a direct reflection of the parts of our story that we have not addressed. And so the really good news is that sexual difficulties are not this life sentence to struggle or to addiction. They can actually become a roadmap to healing and growth.

Alex Kocher (09:10.37)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (09:32.023)

And so to me, that's what I think the gospel is all about is yes, there are present patterns of sin and brokenness that need to be confronted, but we do that so that the wider work of the gospel to bring healing and change and redemption into our lives. So that was some of the background of Unwanted, but happy to answer any other questions or talk more about personal stuff or whatever direction you'd like to go.

Brenda Payne (09:33.776)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (09:48.82)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (09:49.495)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (09:53.596)

Mm-hmm.

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (10:02.353)

Yeah, I just wanna say one one or two comments about what you said. It's all so good. I I think just this idea of people being stuck and you can't get out it it

It honestly begins to almost diminish the power of the gospel in people's minds. And they get so discouraged, right? You talked about the self-hatred and self-contempt. It's like, what's wrong with me? I can't get over this. I can't get over this. But we just keep going back to the same old ways. And that's definitely how I was taught to deal with lust and to teach people how to deal with lust is very much on the surface of the of the behavior and the thinking, but never going to desire. And then as I was reading your book and as you were talking, I was thinking, this is just really uncomfortable, Jay, for people to talk about. Like you're asking people.

Alex Kocher (10:27.286)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (10:40.253)

To ask somebody about their sexual fantasies, much less have somebody talk about their sexual fantasies. Like how do we even get to a point in the church that we can have those kind of honest conversations and and honestly not even feel like we're being defiled ourselves in that?

Jay Stringer (10:54.221)

Mm-hmm. Yep. So I I mean I think of like sex is taken from this Latin word secare, which means to sever or to amputate from the whole. So some theologians will talk about our sexuality as different than just our genitality. So Ronald Rollheiser has this example of like when you see a widow crying at a funeral, that is an expression of her sexuality that

She has been connected with this husband of 30 years, 50 years, and he's now gone. And in the grief, there is so much agony, so much heartache. And that's an expression of sexuality. Is how do we begin to, you know, address that sense of separation. So all of us, when we are growing up, are navigating things like

Our mothers, our fathers, our adverse childhood experiences, and all of those shape our sexuality. So, you know, Dan Siegel would talk about how children need what he refers to as the four S's to be seen, to be safe, soothed, and secure. And so, you know, I'll I'll take let's look at kind of seen and soothed just briefly. But we are made, we are we grow up as Kurt Thompson says.

Brenda Payne (11:55.272)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (12:13.839)

We grow up looking for someone looking for us and that never stops. So a good mother, a good father is gonna be like, Jay, you love Mr. T's ice cream in Chattanooga, Tennessee. you know, it's after dinner, let's go to Mr. T's ice cream, because that's gonna bring you a sense of delight. But also I think about middle school as like a prototype of hell. And all of us have had bullies,

Alex Kocher (12:17.312)

Mm, mm.

Brenda Payne (12:18.461)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (12:28.908)

Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (12:37.683)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (12:42.479)

Difficulties with algebra, heartaches that we've gone through. And it's that sense of did you have a mother or a father that saw that something in your face had changed? Or when you were going off on this great adventure or experiencing something that was anxiety provoking? Like, did you have parents that helped you move through that and saw you with that? Well, if you didn't experience that.

Alex Kocher (12:52.704)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (13:09.285)

That doesn't just evaporate. That need doesn't just go. So a lot of my clients would talk about the first experiences of porn were not just about like, you know, it could have been some version of sex ed that they had never received and they were very, very curious. But some of them talk about I would just look at porn for hours just trying to find the right set of eyes. And it's like, that's really intriguing. The right set of eyes. And it's like they just wanted to be seen. That's how it started.

Brenda Payne (13:32.744)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (13:33.716)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (13:37.937)

Hmm. Yeah.

Alex Kocher (13:39.517)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (13:39.521)

Or soothing. you know, all of us, especially when we're first born, like when a newborn comes into the world, they are so dependent on skin to skin contact, of like being able to regulate their body temperature, their nervous system. So much stuff comes online in the brain through the soothing of a mother and father. And so just that sense of did you have a parent that provided relational soothing?

Brenda Payne (13:55.955)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (14:08.311)

in the midst of your distress. But a lot of us grew up with families that maybe we were a latchkey kid and we didn't get much soothing. But more than likely your mom or your dad were actually the source of your distress. And then because you couldn't go to relationship, because you couldn't go to family, you recruited a third to help you. And so that's the madness of all addictive behaviors is I don't like my life. I don't like my family. I don't like who I am.

Alex Kocher (14:20.716)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (14:29.62)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (14:29.864)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (14:37.997)

So I recruit a third to become the solution to a problem, but then the solution becomes the problem. And that's kind of Isaiah 44 is you know, this hunk of wood, you carve it into, you know, it gives light to the camp, you cook your food over it, but you also carve it into this ornate structure that becomes an idol and you put your trust in it. And so the

Alex Kocher (14:41.94)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (14:46.237)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (14:49.204)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (15:01.654)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (15:01.821)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (15:04.003)

Long way of answering your original question is we have to kind of begin to say that our sexual fantasies are making sense of some of the heartache and trauma that we have been through in our lives. So my relationship with my mom, I would say, was a very triangulated and emotionally enmeshed relationship. So growing up as a pastor's family, my dad has a lot of pastoral crises that he's dealing with, and my mom will

Brenda Payne (15:16.146)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (15:33.195)

Often, not always, but often confide in me first about the difficulties that she had in her marriage, in her friendships, with my other siblings. So it's not, you know, sexual in the classic sense, but I became very, very good at reading a mother's heartache and sadness, and then being brought into very intimate scenes between us in a way that my siblings didn't.

Brenda Payne (15:41.01)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (15:46.952)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (15:52.684)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (15:53.021)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (16:01.165)

And so by the time that I got to grad school and high school, people would call me essentially like Candyman J was a joke because I had this emotional candy that I would like ask the question that they've been waiting to be asked. some women would say, Okay, you have like a sixth sense for knowing where my boyfriend or my husband is disappointing me, and you present yourself

Brenda Payne (16:01.831)

Hm.

Brenda Payne (16:18.947)

Hmm.

Alex Kocher (16:19.646)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (16:26.023)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (16:27.875)

right in the middle of that. And it's it that was conscious to me, but also unconscious. I was playing that out. But the genre of pornography that I got really bound to in seminary and college had to do with mother oriented themes. And so again, how do I talk about that while I'm going through seminary? You know, I'm a man struggling with porn, struggling with an eating disorder.

Alex Kocher (16:32.993)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (16:43.687)

Hm.

Jay Stringer (16:52.143)

and not a lot of places to begin to talk about that. So I'm feeling profound levels of shame. And yet that was part of the gift of therapy for me was like my sexual fantasies, my way of relating to women, my food disorders were not random at all. They were trying to get my attention about patterns and dynamics and relationships that I had never addressed before. So

Brenda Payne (16:53.821)

Hm.

Brenda Payne (17:11.027)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (17:18.909)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (17:19.695)

That relationship with my mom shaped my sexual fantasies. It shaped how I presented myself in the world to be enjoyed, to be admired, to kind of begin some dynamic of I I know where your husband is failing you. I know where your boyfriend is failing you. And it and so that was the the difficult thing for me is to build that scaffolding to be able to say.

Alex Kocher (17:25.236)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (17:39.328)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (17:40.678)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (17:47.183)

There's so much that we can learn from our symptoms. And most of us are not curious about what our symptoms are trying to teach us. we try and manage them, we try and get rid of them. we do almost anything we can to not get very curious about why we do the things that we do.

Alex Kocher (17:50.646)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (17:51.997)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (17:56.821)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (18:06.803)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (18:08.512)

Hm. Yeah, Jay, I wanna say, first, Unwanted is one of the very few books, it's one of two actually, that I actually will go chapter by chapter through with someone in counseling, which I just think so says so so much about what your your br the questions you're bringing is like I I

I I don't always do it, but I often find myself like saying, Hey, we need to go through this chapter by chapter because for me, what I think being at the Allen Dor Center, was at the Alander Center for three years and we had we had to do our sexual story. I remember thinking, I don't I don't think I have a sexual story. And I mean even just that, like what is my sexual story was was a rocking question. And then for you to take it the next step of like how does that sexual story that I do have

shape what I'm experiencing in my sexual relationships in my thought life now. And for me, to be honest with you, it wasn't because I experienced sexual abuse or had a pornography addiction. So I just think the question is so good, even for people who are not experiencing addiction, but it's just

How do I view sex? How do I approach sex with my husband? It led to great conversations in counseling room, but it great conversations with my husband. So just so appreciative of the of the work. And I and I want people Yeah, I want people to hear that you you don't have to be in what you would call addiction to benefit from this book. The questions are just so helpful. And you have a way of

Jay Stringer (19:33.061)

Well.

Thank you for sharing that.

Brenda Payne (19:46.023)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (19:49.071)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (19:51.686)

very gently taking us to those places that I I really appreciate. It could easily be bomb a kind of a bombastic, you know, like you gotta go here, you know. And you have a way of doing that very gently.

Brenda Payne (19:56.019)

Ha ha ha.

Jay Stringer (20:00.877)

Mm-hmm. Yes. One of the most helpful things I learned from Dan Allender was you know, I I was dating my now wife Heather when I was in grad school. My dad had made the decision to leave being a pastor to come out to the Seattle school to study under Dan. So my girlfriend and my dad are in Allender's class sexual disorders together.

Alex Kocher (20:19.507)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (20:26.765)

And I'm on the outside lecturing, hearing him talk, and he says this the bedroom is the noisiest room in the entire house. It said your porn history is there, your abuse history is there, your mother is there, your father is there, and I'm like, This is too close to home to have this woman that I am sexually attracted to and my father in the same room, and just trying to work.

Brenda Payne (20:36.347)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (20:36.363)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (20:40.359)

Well.

Alex Kocher (20:42.939)

Yes. Yeah.

Brenda Payne (20:45.222)

Ha ha ha.

Jay Stringer (20:54.843)

through that, but it was such a gift to be able to say we don't enter marriage as this blank slate. It's all of this, like you know, the the messages that we've inherited. you know, I I think my grandmother Dorothy had unaddressed sexual trauma that she'd never wanted to be able to talk about.

Alex Kocher (21:01.15)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (21:01.19)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (21:15.289)

So I have an inheritance of sexual shame, an inheritance of sexual assault, and all of that, just from what we know of epigenetics and the study of gene expression from generation to generation, all of that goes into our own sexual story. And to what both of you have said, we don't have language training. Even professional therapists may be one class in human sexuality.

Brenda Payne (21:35.612)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (21:39.969)

Imagine going to a cardiologist who's only had one class in the human heart. You wouldn't see them, and yet somehow we've known this for thousands of years that like church leaders and pastors and leaders are not sexually healthy. They don't know their own story and like but we still expect masterpieces and that they know what to do and how to navigate these difficulties. And from where I sit, there's no one without a symptom.

Brenda Payne (21:40.058)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (21:44.659)

Right.

Brenda Payne (21:55.716)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (22:00.638)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (22:04.146)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (22:07.525)

There's no one without some place of agony or difficulty. And so part of the invitation is what can we learn from these difficulties? And so, you know, when Adam has just eaten of the tree that he was commanded not to eat from, God doesn't say bounce your eyes and let's do some tree management. He says, Where are you? To Jacob, who's been struggling, it's like, what is your name? To Hagar, who's been traumatized by the first family of the faith.

Alex Kocher (22:08.789)

Right.

Brenda Payne (22:26.15)

Ha ha ha

Alex Kocher (22:27.423)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (22:32.243)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (22:34.955)

Angel of the Lord shows up for the first time and says, Like, where do you come from? Where are you going? And those are two of the best questions that we can ask ourselves if we're in some sexual, relational, behavioral pattern that is just crazy making, is to say, okay, where does this pattern come from and where is it going? Like one of the things I was reading this morning was doing more work around men and bodies and you know, just this.

Alex Kocher (22:40.339)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (22:40.678)

Mm-hmm.

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (22:50.803)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (23:03.277)

notion of muscle dysmorphia. And one of the authors was saying one of the things he's seen is a lot of men, he more anecdotally, that are struggling with, you know, needing to be big, kind of bigorexia is what they've referred to it some as, grew up in homes with domestic violence where they were watching their powerful dominant father abuse and humiliate their mom. And that has to go somewhere. So

Brenda Payne (23:05.756)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (23:29.83)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (23:31.146)

Right.

Jay Stringer (23:31.575)

Some people might say, I hate my body, I hate how small my body is, or I hate how big my body is, but your relationship to your body is not random. So you have to go back to some of those stories that informed why do you view your body as so big? Why do you view it as so small? Why do you view it as unhealthy? And so that's just our physical body. But then the internal thoughts

Alex Kocher (23:40.383)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (23:41.03)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (23:47.817)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (23:48.188)

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (23:56.675)

realities that will come across anybody's radar system with regard to sex. it is a very, very, back to Alander's phrase, like the noisiest room in the entire house. And most of us don't have a season where we're able to get curious about why do I think this way? Why do I why is this what brings me to orgasm? Or why is sexual arousal so threatening to me? And it's just easier to kind of go offline and

Alex Kocher (24:01.781)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (24:08.127)

Noisy, mhm, mhm.

Brenda Payne (24:09.798)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (24:15.708)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (24:16.083)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (24:20.849)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (24:23.603)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (24:24.37)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (24:26.639)

Maybe need a defibrillator for my sex life than to have to deal with too much desire. So the symptoms of our life are communicating. I just don't think we're trained well to listen to them.

Alex Kocher (24:29.849)

Mm. Mm.

Brenda Payne (24:32.592)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (24:38.847)

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So we've mainly been talking about unwanted, but I'm curious how your thinking developed after you wrote Unwanted and was there a conversation you thought was missing that led you to write Desire?

Brenda Payne (24:39.354)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (24:53.721)

Yes. so unwanted was great for what it did. Like it helped bring curiosity to some of these places of sexual shame and difficulty. But then I started realizing like this isn't just about outgrowing one paradigm. It's that we have like no understanding of how to develop a healthy relationship to desire. So just kind of continuing to go even further upstream.

And not sure about you all, but like you know, I think desire is responsible for all the best, most beautiful things in my world. Like desire is responsible for my wife Heather, for my children, for unwanted, for desire being released in the world. And yet, if I'm honest, like my desires also led me to Heather. They led me to write unwanted and all the madness that that created in my life. And

Alex Kocher (25:31.029)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (25:35.792)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (25:49.36)

You know, most of us have some area of it could be a sexual difficulty, could be alcoholism, could be our own greed, our own envy. So we have something of the civil war where desire is making me beautiful, it's bringing me life. But if I'm honest, desire has also wreaked havoc. Like it's led me to shame, it's led me to selfishness. And then you grow up in, you know, a family system, a church system where they say, you know, the heart is deceitfully wicked.

Brenda Payne (25:49.628)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (26:19.215)

Who can trust it? Or God wants to give you the desires of your heart. And you're like, what do I do with these competing messages? And then you get into more progressive culture and it's like, I love, love, love the line from the poet Mary Oliver. What is it that you want to do with this one wild and precious life that you've been given? But there's no framework for how to disciple your desire or how to grow it into this place of connection, purpose, and love.

Brenda Payne (26:24.284)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (26:26.839)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (26:38.234)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (26:42.111)

Right.

Brenda Payne (26:43.078)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (26:46.595)

And so I started realizing like people are just going into desire with like really toxic, harmful messages that they should never develop their desires. Or some people are being encouraged to follow their heart and their desires, but they have no framework to understand why I desire anything that I desire. So I came across like a very brief research study where these researchers gave people word pairings. And so one person was given the

Brenda Payne (26:59.452)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (27:14.991)

the word pairing ocean moon. And then like 15 minutes later, the researchers said, What's your favorite detergent? And what those people that had been given ocean moon answered, they answered tide in a statistically much more significant way. And so what the researchers said was this desire preferences can be primed into us without our conscious awareness. So that's just like with our detergent.

Alex Kocher (27:41.173)

Wow. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (27:41.788)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (27:43.459)

So when you think about the American dream, when you think about the type of sex that you want, when you think about what you want to do with your backyard, with your life, ⁓ our desires are not random. And so we need to have not like a hyper-vigilant scrutiny around our desires, but we need some healthy suspicion around why do I want what I want? maybe it's healthy, maybe it's trauma-informed, maybe there's a billion-

Brenda Payne (27:59.506)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (28:06.258)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (28:06.863)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (28:13.327)

Dollar tech company that is priming my desires. And so we need to have some healthy interrogation for those things. So that was part of it. And then the final thing would just be a lot of people would write in to say, you know, it's not that I don't have it, you know, you wrote unwanted. I'm learning about it, like I'm using it as a eating disorder book, or I'm using it as a

other type of book, but it's like, what do I do if I don't feel like I have desire for anything? And that's that defibrillator. The light has gone dim in that woman's eyes and that man's eyes. And it's it's about it could be about sex, but it could just be about their career, their marriage. but just something in their soul has literally become depressed. And so for all those people, whether you felt like desire was too much or you felt like I couldn't get it started.

Alex Kocher (28:42.26)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (28:42.661)

Mm. Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (28:52.914)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (29:04.547)

I wanted to provide a framework for how do we grow desire.

Alex Kocher (29:09.876)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (29:10.073)

Mm-hmm.

Yeah, I think you've done that so well in the book Desire as well. And I just think about when I first became a Christian and even early on in my Christian training, how much focus there was on biblical thinking, right? Don't be transformed, but be renewed by you know through your mind. And so there was a lot of think right, think right, no more truth, think right. If you think right, you're gonna behave right. And so all of this just tying and the the ironic thing is we were never taught to think about our desires. That wasn't being thought about and how what our current desires were or how those desires were formed.

Alex Kocher (29:37.882)

Hm.

Brenda Payne (29:40.868)

And Alex and I actually speak a lot about this. We have a little our four core desires that we have are a little bit different, but they would fit right along with yours coming right out of Genesis 1 and 2 and being made in the image of God. And so I would love for you to talk a little bit about what are our core desires and and what does it look like to become curious? Because I can see some people that all they've ever been taught is how to think and how to act. And so this area of desires is very foreign. When we're talking about understand your desires, get curious about your desires, what part of us are we even talking about?

Jay Stringer (30:10.317)

Mm-hmm. So we broke desire up into five different desires. so think about these not as like a la carte menu options that you get to pick or choose from. These are you gotta have all five. So people in the research that like had really meaningful work, really intimate relationships, had great confidence in their adult lives, and

Brenda Payne (30:23.323)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (30:39.151)

They were doing these five things. So those five desires are a desire for wholeness, which is all about a desire to understand your family of origin, to understand some of the difficulties of your life. And what I'll often say is that the wounds of childhood are healed through our adult commitment to offer that boy, that girl, kindness, attunement. And so the desire for wholeness is all about going back.

Then there's the desire for personal growth. And that's all about differentiation. Like, how do you become the type of person that you deeply enjoy? Because the reality for a lot of people is they hate themselves. They don't like who they are. And so then they give their spouse, their friends a laundry list of needs to be able to validate them, to soothe them, or in a narcissistic way, they need their job to.

Alex Kocher (31:22.483)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (31:28.699)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (31:34.629)

Be a reflection back to them of their worth. And so they put a lot of pressure on the world around them to desire them because they don't enjoy who they are. So a desire for personal growth is all about differentiation, developing hospitality for the difficulties of your life. And then the third desire is a desire for intimacy and just the reality that all of us are underdeveloped when we arrive at the stage of relationships.

Brenda Payne (31:42.511)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (31:53.499)

Hm.

Jay Stringer (32:03.277)

And so the good news is that a desire for intimacy is a skill that we can develop. There's ways that we can grow and increase intimacy. And then there's the desire for pleasure, which is all about, you know, just how do I develop good desires for sex, for pleasure, to give and to receive love? And then finally is that sense of a desire for meaning and purpose in your life.

Brenda Payne (32:03.857)

Hmm.

Jay Stringer (32:28.983)

And so just again, we we need all five. So you get some people that think, Yeah, I crush desire. I have entrepreneurial interests. I'm really good at my career, but then their marriage is imploding. Or you get some people that become like therapy all stars and they're like, I have such a desire for, you know, that small boy and that small girl and I'm gonna be caring for them. But then they have no n, you know, awareness or desire to like

Brenda Payne (32:36.059)

Ha ha ha.

Brenda Payne (32:40.869)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (32:56.431)

be a transitional character in their city or within their family of origin. So it's a bit like checks and balances where you need to develop all five of these desires. So

Brenda Payne (33:05.371)

Yeah.

Mm.

Alex Kocher (33:11.539)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (33:12.005)

Hm, that's really well said. Thank you.

Jay Stringer (33:12.869)

That's the thirty thousand foot overview. But like to your point, like it l let me you know, the other when I when I wrote Desire, can talk about this maybe in another episode, but I've been in like my own midlife chrysalis this past year. Like twenty twenty six has been the hardest year of my adult life. and in the midst of this, my brother in law got me a

Brenda Payne (33:16.422)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (33:33.919)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (33:34.289)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (33:41.647)

Basically, a spa experience for a facial at a very expensive spa in the Upper West Side and Manhattan where I live. And I grew up as a pastor's kid. Like I remember going to like Chili's when we'd go out to lunch after church. And it was like, we're not going to Taco Bell today. We're going to Chili's. Like there's a waiter. and I remember seeing like

Brenda Payne (33:48.805)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (33:57.835)

Ha ha

Alex Kocher (34:06.172)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (34:06.691)

I could get an old timer for like nine fifty and then maybe like an old timer with cheese for like an extra twenty five cents. And I would not order the cheese because I was like just knew the financial stress that my parents were under. So scarcity, some level of, you know, financial concern is just hardwired into my system. So when my brother in law bought this very, very expensive thing for me, I was like, No, I'm not doing it. I c like I can

Brenda Payne (34:23.405)

huh.

Mm.

Brenda Payne (34:33.061)

Ha ha

Jay Stringer (34:36.089)

get over like I might be the only man getting a facial that day didn't concern me, but the money. And so I go in, start talking to the woman that's gonna tend to me for about an hour. And, you know, she does the steam and then she eventually makes some like manuka honey mixture. And it is warm and like just feels like the most sensual experience I think my face has ever known.

Brenda Payne (34:39.577)

Ha ha ha

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (35:06.169)

And I'm getting this done, fighting it, and I just start weeping. because I mean, so much of my own self-hatred as a middle school boy, a lot of the harm that my face has known in bullying and in my own self-contempt, that's part of what I felt like I had to grapple with in that. And so, Brenda, to your point, like I have tried to renew my mind, I've tried to be kind, I've tried to like

Do all these things in my mind. I know all the verses, but I mean I can weep just thinking about it. Like being embodied, where I have to receive kindness to a place that has been a war zone, and I'm receiving comfort and sensuality and goodness and beauty, that unnerved me. And that was part of that sense of I remember thinking.

Brenda Payne (35:38.959)

Right.

Jay Stringer (35:57.977)

Like I'm doing this on behalf of that boy. I'm also doing this on behalf of all stringer men that I can be for dang sure have never received anything of this level of goodness. But then I started thinking about eternity, where it's like, what will it be like for my body to be in the presence of a man who wants to get down on his knees to cleanse my feet, to bring goodness to what I've known. And so that that's like

Alex Kocher (36:22.932)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (36:27.387)

part of just even how this book has been working on me where it's like, yeah, like that desire to go back to that 13 year old boy in his body. But then also what's the self-contempt and how do I need to engage that and bring, you know, my wife, my kids into like a face that is not a war zone, that actually wants to receive goodness. And is my face free for the kingdom of God?

To actually bring my face to a podcast, to bring my face to a stage to speak. And that's where it's again, desire, I have to desire all of it in order to really flourish. And we need to be embodied in that process. And that's where just a prayer and a journal are just really not gonna really develop our desires to the degree that I think we really need to. So I always think of just like that parable of the talents. I know it's not theologically

Brenda Payne (36:52.857)

Hmm.

Jay Stringer (37:22.071)

accurate to exegete it entirely in that way, but like the master has given so many desires inside of our hearts. And the the heart you know, the harshest words in the parable the talents are those that don't develop their talents. And to me that's what desire is is we have all these talents, all these longings, all these desires inside of us. And I think that's part of what God is asking is, are you developing those desires?

Brenda Payne (37:31.001)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (37:37.48)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (37:37.901)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (37:50.302)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (37:50.439)

Mm-hmm.

I think you just described such a beautiful picture of redemption, right? Like this is how I did view my ve my face. And because of what Jesus has done for me now, this is how my face is being used face forward for the kingdom of God and to tell people about the truth and set them free. And that is a work of the spirit. And I I kind of feel like we could I mean, even the world has a a way of renewing your mind, right? The cognitive behavior therapy. Like we can go to that and say people can change their thinking, but I think to have the desire

From God and for God and of God. That is such a work of the Holy Spirit that that level of change and desire has got to be a work of the Spirit. And that is that deep level. And comfort does change us in a way that conviction and forgiveness of sin does not. It just is different. It's a different, there are different ways that the Holy Spirit comes and brings comfort and change that I think warms our hearts so much that we can't we have to change. It just it's going to change us. It's just beautiful.

Alex Kocher (38:48.564)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (38:51.011)

So well said. Yeah. Yeah. Thomas Merton says, like, to say that we are made in the image of God is to say that love is the reason of for our existence. And I love that notion of like if it's if it's true that I'm made in the image of God as a man, as a woman, like love is the reason for my existence. And that's unsettling to be able to kind of say it's not about what I can offer. It's not about being useful to someone or helpful to someone.

Brenda Payne (38:51.027)

Beautiful.

Alex Kocher (38:52.67)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (39:01.182)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (39:01.701)

Yes. Yes.

Alex Kocher (39:12.938)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (39:13.379)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (39:20.643)

It's about love. And that that's I think what the spirit begins to testify is like you are deeply loved and enjoyed. And you know, you all know as therapists and working with people, people will talk about their sexual sin, their difficulties, how much time they spend on their screens, the failure that they've done to their kids. But you ask people to talk about where they're beautiful and what is stunning about them, and they will run for the hills.

Brenda Payne (39:26.511)

Yeah. Yes, yes.

Jay Stringer (39:48.609)

it will be like they will discredit themselves and maneuver their way out of having to be do that. So I think that's Lewis's point is we're so much more afraid of joy than we are of pain.

Brenda Payne (39:52.068)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (39:52.168)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (39:58.947)

Mm, great point. Great point. Mm. Mm. Such a such a good word.

Alex Kocher (40:02.952)

Mm-hmm.

I th I think you Brenda, you when you opened and Jay, it was we talked about unwanted w we I think it may be easy for people to see the connection between desires and shame and self-contempt. But in your story, you're connecting getting in touch with our desires and grief. And that might not be something that people connect as easily. And I wonder if you could just talk about the relationship between desire and grief.

Jay Stringer (40:33.965)

Mm-hmm. Yeah, like it I mean, I think about there's so many desires that we are chasing that could be released if we allowed ourselves to grieve. So when I was growing up, I used to think about narcissism as a sense of being full of oneself. So I won't name names, but the the guy in my high school was Trace, we'll call him Tracy, and he had like a Ford Mustang Cobra.

Alex Kocher (40:55.626)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (41:03.119)

He always needed to be dressed in the like Tommy Hill figure, always needed to have the most attractive person. So we would say that Trey was full of himself. But what I learned in clinical training is that narcissism is not actually a fullness of self, it's an absence of self. And so if you don't know who you are, you're always recruiting a third. You're always recruiting something from the outside to reflect back to you your worth. And so when you think about like a desire for a

Brenda Payne (41:03.14)

Yeah.

Brenda Payne (41:10.394)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (41:18.665)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (41:21.488)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (41:32.281)

Certain amount of money or a desire for a certain type of spouse or a certain type of body, you might hate yourself. And that's what you're chasing your desires for. But if you could get in touch with, maybe I wasn't dealing with just a poverty of being in a minister family, but far more a poverty of love, the grief of that's gonna change what I begin to pursue. And so grief has the potential to set a lot of those destructive.

Desires free. And I just I think shame has such a high ROI. So, you know, when you hate your face, you're gonna pursue a lot of products and a lot of lifestyle choices to begin to try and mitigate that self-hatred. But what if you began to grieve how little your face was actually seen, intended to, and cared for? That could change everything. But it, you know, comfort is what we

Alex Kocher (42:04.638)

Mm. Yeah.

Brenda Payne (42:09.956)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (42:29.539)

need so much of that we also don't really begin to experience. So that's always, you know, the thing with therapy or, you know, people can fund, especially here in New York where I live, it's like they can go on like the best vacations, they can, you know, optimize everything, spend so much on themselves. But what's so rare is just having a face that's able to read them and care for them. So I I I will see that often as, yeah.

Brenda Payne (42:32.856)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (42:36.368)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (42:54.148)

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (42:58.095)

People end up chasing something and they don't ever stop to say maybe there's a harm, maybe there's a source of shame that's driving this and if I could grieve it and experience comfort, could I be set free from that desire? But also desire comfort as well.

Brenda Payne (43:01.753)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (43:10.224)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (43:13.747)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (43:14.096)

Yeah.

Yeah, yeah. I think we're gonna have to for sake of time start

Alex Kocher (43:17.083)

Right. Yeah. Yeah.

Brenda Payne (43:21.068)

Wrapping up, I want to ask one last question and then maybe we'll invite you back because I think we have so many other questions. It's been such an incredible interview and just so rich. but a lot of times, I'm gonna say, particularly maybe in some Christian circles more than others, there's a real fear about talking about our past and looking back, talking about longings and how those play in, because I think the real fear is that we're going to excuse sin.

Jay Stringer (43:26.757)

For sure.

Brenda Payne (43:47.757)

So how do we cultivate this posture that you're talking about of all the things you've said this podcast, but remain faithful to biblical holiness and the understanding that we are we are in fact sinners as well.

Jay Stringer (44:01.699)

Mm-hmm. Yeah. So I you know, one of the things that I will think about with regard to sin is that yes, we need to grapple with the notion of sin, but we also have to understand like the way that I sin is not random. the I have to study part of the ways that I have been sinned against in order to understand that. So my sin as Jay Stringer is not random.

Alex Kocher (44:20.189)

Right.

Jay Stringer (44:29.997)

So when I grew up in a family that I was much more the golden child. and you know, just that sense of can I bring my darkness? Can I bring my heartache? Can I bring stuff to my parents? for the most part I could not. So there's this object relations theorist by the name of D.W. Winnicott. And one of the things he says is good parenting is like what we see Jesus doing on the cross.

Which is just impossible standard. But what he says is that Jesus had to be so impacted by sin, by the heartache and scapegoating of humanity. He needed to be vulnerable enough to be put to death, but also he was strong enough to be able to survive that. And in the midst of that, we know that we can develop more of a secure attachment with Jesus because he can he can deal with the worst in us.

And so borrowing from that, that's what we needed. That's the importance of going back. Is if you didn't have a place to bring all of your anxiety to, all of your, you know, sexual difficulties, dread, anger, entitlement, the family is the place to be able to work through all that. And if you didn't have that, more than likely you are using your relationships to work that out. So when I look at a lot of my adult history and dating.

Brenda Payne (45:22.981)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (45:52.127)

just so much entitlement, so much abusive engagement, because for the first time I'm dating someone and there's so much unaddressed anger inside of me. And so I will see that as yes, like that is my sin, but I also grieve that like this place of anger was never invited in my own family. I needed to be good at the cost of being honest. And so that's I think.

Part of the invitation to be able to go back to trauma, to heartache. But also, like if you think about Holy Week, Holy Week is, you know, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Friday is a day of trauma. It's a day of heartache. Jesus' body was physically abused. Some scholars would say that there was a level of sexual abuse done against his body, just given crucifixion under Roman guards. So Friday.

Is a day of trauma, and many of us think if I'm going to make something known about Jesus, I just need to tell a redemptive story. I need to get right to Easter. And I don't think that that's true. I think as we tell our Friday stories of heartache, of abuse, and we grieve and we allow the softness of our face to be seen and that vulnerability of how excruciating it is. Or Holy Saturday is a day of if you've been following a Messiah for three

Brenda Payne (47:00.08)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (47:19.131)

Three years of your life and now he's dead. What do you think you're gonna feel? Devastated. And how many of us have had hopes for a child, hopes for a marriage, hopes for a career? And you have been waiting three years, 10 years, 20 years, and it all vanishes. What do you feel? You feel Holy Saturday inside. And so, you know, to me, if you want to become like Jesus, it's not just about feeling.

powerful and I can do all things through Christ who strengtheneth me. It's also a sense of I I want to get to know a man of sorrows because I find myself to be a man of sorrows this year. And so is there something about even some of the present difficulties of my life that is allowing myself to know something of who Jesus was and what Good Friday was for me. So I I just don't think you can really

Become like Jesus if you're disconnected from your past. If you're disconnected. I mean, think about Jesus' bloodline and all the women and assaults and sexuality that's part of Jesus' maternal bloodline. It's I mean, it's just it's it there's so much about the past that the gospel writers are working into the present. So to me, sin is always an invitation to be.

Brenda Payne (48:16.528)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (48:33.637)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (48:39.598)

Mm mm. So good.

Alex Kocher (48:40.177)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (48:44.121)

Honest about who I am. But if I'm working with a client who cannot be honest about their heartache and the betrayal that they have felt in their family of origin, I already know that their mirror neurons are not going to be able to step into how they're hurting and betraying their spouse. So honesty is a muscle that develops the more that you use it. And sometimes we wonder why they are so dishonest in their marriage? Why are they so like

Brenda Payne (48:49.733)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (49:04.68)

Mm-hmm.

Brenda Payne (49:05.24)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (49:10.03)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (49:12.783)

lack empathy and it's like, that's not random. So if we could go back and attend to that, we're not making excuses for that behavior. We're trying to bring greater honesty into the present.

Brenda Payne (49:18.672)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (49:19.177)

Mm.

Alex Kocher (49:29.221)

Mm. Yeah. Yeah. And I think you're putting such great words, JC. We we we were t we were very much schooled in the put off put on principle, right? And I and I like to say like we forget the middle part of like by the renewing of our minds. And I think you're putting s some language to the ways that we renew our minds and how the how going into our past helps us even understand how our mind was shaped for it to even to begin to be renewed. So I I'll

Brenda Payne (49:29.514)

Mm. That's so well, said Jay. So good.

Brenda Payne (49:40.335)

Mm-hmm.

Alex Kocher (49:57.588)

You're weaving together some really great concepts and I'm I'm pointing that out because I I want our listeners to hear the things that we've always been taught and then hear how you're nuancing it and bringing complexity to it. And you do that in all of your writing, you in all of your speaking, and we we really appreciate that.

Brenda Payne (50:10.191)

Mm-hmm.

Jay Stringer (50:16.549)

Thank you.

Brenda Payne (50:16.568)

Yeah.

Alex Kocher (50:18.223)

We want our listeners to be able to benefit from all the resources that you have. You you have your your books, your classes, all of those things. So what's the best way for them to engage with your work and learn more about

Jay Stringer (50:33.281)

My website is JAY Dash Stringer dot com and the reason why there's a Dash is there's also a Jay Stringer that's a British crime fiction novelist. who beat me to all the social media handles and websites. So some people have said, Well you all ever work on a book together, which I think would be fun to bring that together, but

Alex Kocher (50:36.945)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (50:44.153)

Good to know.

Alex Kocher (50:44.61)

Ha ha ha.

Brenda Payne (50:51.983)

Right. That's great.

Jay Stringer (50:56.037)

That website has, you know, information about intensives, information about, you know, we took a lot of the research that we did for unwanted and desire and turned it into self-assessments. So instead of just kind of like wondering where your problems lie or why you're doing what you're doing, the desire self-assessment will help you to see like what desires are really strong inside, but also where you're underdeveloped.

And then the SBSA is kind of that sense of how do you actually renew your mind? so what are your sexual difficulties, fantasies, and then what are the key drivers that are influencing those? And so just we want to give people compass headings of, you know, what's a roadmap to healing and to growth? Because i if our problems are not random, then the problem can actually become something of the roadmap to healing. And so those assessments, resources are all designed to

Alex Kocher (51:34.185)

Mm.

Brenda Payne (51:40.463)

Yeah.

Jay Stringer (51:51.813)

To go deeper.

Brenda Payne (51:53.487)

That's great. Well, thank you, Jay. Thank you for taking time to be with us today. Thank you for your good work. And we just will continue to pray. God's blessings on you and all that you're doing.

Alex Kocher (51:56.307)

Mm.

Jay Stringer (52:02.171)

Thank you. Such a a joy and delight to be with you. So look forward to more.